What would happen if....

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

All you have to do is a a question about if Shannen never left Charmed.

I'll go first.

What if Prue never died and she was still in all the seasons?

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

i don't know if i am meant to answer your question but i will anyway.
From Shannens side:
if Shannen never left Charmed and had been in all the seasons, we wouldn't have been introduced to Rose. Also Shannen might not have been able to apear in the other shows since Charmed.

From Prues side:
We still might no know about Paige being there half sister. Cole might still be in the programme as he might not have turned into the source.The innocents that they have saved since Prues death may not have been saved.Agent Brody may never have been introduced to us. The storys lines may have been better or worse.


What would have happened if Prue got together with Cole instead of Phoebe?

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

I think Phoebe could have been seeing Andy and if she did, he might not have died because everyone has a different way of doing things, such as telling people not to do something.Again, Cole might not have became the Source and could still be alive.

What would happen if Andy was still alive, do you think they would have children?


P.S After someone has answered/replied, you don't have to answer their question but can if you choose to.

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

I think Prue and Andy would have got married,We might again not have met Paige. They might have saved more innocents because at the end of season 7 it seemed like Darryl was starting to ge out of covering for them, and Andy would always cover for them.

i also think they would have had kids i think they would make great parents aswell.

what would have happened if in seson 1 Prue married Rodger?

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

Then I don't think that we would have met Andy, if we did, it wouldn't be a big part like he was in the sisters' lives.Phoebe might even feel guilty because when Roger came onto her Prue believed Roger,or at least she wanted to.

Do you think she would be a good aunt to Wyatt and Chris?

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

i think Prue would be a good aunt she loves kids so the two would go together well.

What if Piper and Prue never moved back to the manor to stay with Grams?

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

Then Phoebe wouldn't have come back to them in that house, she would go to their apartment and Phoebe wouldn't find the Book Of Shadows.

What if Prue was never killed by Shax, would she have died differently?

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

if Prue wasnt killed by Shax, she might have been killed by another Demon or should could have died from another disease or old age.


What if Shannen Doherty was never cast as Prue Halliwell. ( :'(sad thought i know)

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

If Shannen wasn't Prue Halliwell, I'm sure she would be set as another character on Charmed. She would probably be another Halliwell though.

(Holly Marie Combs originally wanted to be Phoebe!)

Do you think Shannen is like her character?

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

i think shannen is quirky like her character and i think they have a similar sense of humour,but i think she would be more fun and up for more for a laugh and muck about more.



what if Pru never worked at bucklands auction house

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

Then she would probably work somewhere else because she has always been the type who likes to have a career and money to pay bills.

If Shannen didn't want to be Prue, who do you think she would be?

[~*lyssiesgirl*~]

I think she would play the role of Piper, as i can see her being the middle sister, but as far as story lines go i see her having phoebes story lines.


What if Alyssa left charmed instead of Shannen?
Would the show be as good?

[*~_CharmedForeva_~*]

I don't know, but I dont think so because then what would happen to Cole? I don't think the show would be on as long because they do single episodes about Phoebe and Cole where it's all about them two but there wouldn't be any more if Alyssa left.

What would happen if...Shannen played Piper, would she still be seeing the same guys as Holly does Piper?